Redcatcher70

Beebe, AR

Senior Member

Joined: 07/28/2003

View Profile

|
I already have a SMART car, a 1995 Geo Metro, 3 cyl, 5 speed.
1. Its ugly.
2. Its small.
3. 42 - 46 mpg, depending on if I have the A/C on.
4. Its smart, it will not go anywhere unless I get in and turn the key.
5. It was way cheaper than $37,000.00!!!!
6. Room for four, but no one will get in and ride with me......
Dave & Pat
1999 Wanderer 230FB
2004 F250, XLT Crew Cab, V10, finally, enough power!
"No kids, no pets, trying to make it to retirement"
|
lesmore49

canada

Senior Member

Joined: 11/25/2004

View Profile

|
~DJ~ wrote: There are some Smart cars running around Boise. I really have to wonder why anyone would buy one.
1. Rediculous price
2. UGLY
3. No room
4. UGLY
5. You can get a much nicer looking, more practical (4 passenger) sedan that gets as good or better mileage for much less money.. 
You're right. It would cost much less to get a Toyota Matrix or a Yaris, Pontiac Vibe or Honda Fit and the gas mileage isn't that far off from the Smart gasser. Also you can fit four , five in a pinch compared to two in the Smart. Cheaper too.
lesmore49
|
Cloud Dancer

San Antonio and Livingston TX USA

Senior Member

Joined: 06/08/2001

View Profile

|
I already have a smart car. It's 4 WD, and the air conditioner works great. It has a fuel capacity of 17 gallons, and I fill up about once a month. It's 14 years old, paid cash for it, and it's mostly used as a towed vehicle.
OTOH my wife's car is a different story (too complicated). But, a SMART car is not the answer for us.
Willie & Betty Sue
Miko & Sparky
2003 41 ft Dutch Star Diesel Pusher/Spartan
Floorplan 4010
Blazer toad & Ranger bassboat
|
Rubiranch

Salt Lake City, UT

Senior Member

Joined: 03/09/2004

View Profile

|
~DJ~ wrote: There are some Smart cars running around Boise. I really have to wonder why anyone would buy one.
1. Rediculous price
2. UGLY
3. No room
4. UGLY
5. You can get a much nicer looking, more practical (4 passenger) sedan that gets as good or better mileage for much less money.. 
Did you mention they are UGLY? 
TV: Mint 1972 Ford F-250 XLT
TT: 1969 19' Excel; entertains 6, feeds 4, sleeps 2
You don't shoot to kill, you shoot to stay alive.
I don't carry because I have to, I carry because I get to.
I like new things-
- when they're 40 years old!
My pictures
|
Guest

USA

Senior Member

Joined: 08/02/2004

View Profile

Offline
|
I'd be more comfortable, richer and getting better gas mileage in my old 1995 Saturn SL stick shift. I got an actual 40 mpg highway with that car routinely on road trips.
Shoulda kept it.
|
|
|
AlGreg

Northern NY, Harlingen, TX

New Member

Joined: 10/15/2007

View Profile

|
I think there is a lot of misinformation about the Smart Car. My wife has one. The price is NOT $37k. It starts at $11,590 for the Smart Pure. This model lacks A/C and other features. My wife bought the Smart Passion that starts at $13,590. This includes A/C (with climate control), power windows, power door locks (remote), stereo with MP3 CD, sun roof, automatic transmition and many other standard features. There is also The Smart Passion Cabriolet, a convertible, that starts at $16,590. My wife's Smart is bright yellow and she ordered it without any options so her price was $13,590 plus tax, etc. It's made by Mercedes Benz, so you can be assured that it is a well built car. Someone said that it looks like a death trap. It is built around a NASCAR style safety cage and has a 4 star crash rating. Our real life gas mileage has been 43-48 mpg. We drive mostly Adirondack Mountain roads and interstates. I have a friend who regularly gets over 50 with his. He pulls his behind his Winnebago and says it makes an excellent dinghy. If you factor in the higher price for premium gas, we would be getting the equivelent of about 40 MPG with regilar.
Someone talked about not being able to fit in it without opening the sun roof. I'm 6'2", 250 lbs and I have pleanty of room. It is a very comfortable car and handles the mountain roads and interstates very well. When you are in one, it feels like a much larger car.
Someone mentioned the Chevy Volt. That will be priced (when they come out) at about $35,000. The Smart Car is here NOW and can save you a lot of money on gas. The reason that a diesel is not avalible in the USA has nothing to do with Smart not wanting to market it here. It is our government that has kept it out. It is a 2 seater so it is not for everyone, but for us it makes an excellent second car.
Ugly???? I hope I'm around when someone tells my wife that her "baby" is ugly!
Al
|
Kajtek1

CA

Senior Member

Joined: 12/04/2002

View Profile

|
AlGreg wrote: I think there is a lot of misinformation about the Smart Car. My wife has one. The price is NOT $37k. It starts at $11,590 for the Smart Pure.
Took 25 replies to get someone who actually knows something about the subject.
Only on Internet?
Pessimist sees dark tunnel, optimist sees a light at the end, realist sees lights of coming train.Engineer sees 3 idiots on the tracks.
|
JackD

Montreal, Qc,Canada (when not on the road)

Senior Member

Joined: 02/11/2001

View Profile

Offline
|
Everytime I bring in my "real" Mercedes in for service at my local dealer, I insist on having a SMART as a loaner, just for the fun of it.
Fortunately, the turbo diesel version was sold in Canada. 60mpg is the norm.
|
~DJ~

Boise, Idaho

Senior Member

Joined: 05/10/2005

View Profile

|
AlGreg wrote: I think there is a lot of misinformation about the Smart Car. My wife has one. The price is NOT $37k. It starts at $11,590 for the Smart Pure. This model lacks A/C and other features. My wife bought the Smart Passion that starts at $13,590. This includes A/C (with climate control), power windows, power door locks (remote), stereo with MP3 CD, sun roof, automatic transmition and many other standard features. There is also The Smart Passion Cabriolet, a convertible, that starts at $16,590. My wife's Smart is bright yellow and she ordered it without any options so her price was $13,590 plus tax, etc. It's made by Mercedes Benz, so you can be assured that it is a well built car. Someone said that it looks like a death trap. It is built around a NASCAR style safety cage and has a 4 star crash rating. Our real life gas mileage has been 43-48 mpg. We drive mostly Adirondack Mountain roads and interstates. I have a friend who regularly gets over 50 with his. He pulls his behind his Winnebago and says it makes an excellent dinghy. If you factor in the higher price for premium gas, we would be getting the equivelent of about 40 MPG with regilar.
Someone talked about not being able to fit in it without opening the sun roof. I'm 6'2", 250 lbs and I have pleanty of room. It is a very comfortable car and handles the mountain roads and interstates very well. When you are in one, it feels like a much larger car.
Someone mentioned the Chevy Volt. That will be priced (when they come out) at about $35,000. The Smart Car is here NOW and can save you a lot of money on gas. The reason that a diesel is not avalible in the USA has nothing to do with Smart not wanting to market it here. It is our government that has kept it out. It is a 2 seater so it is not for everyone, but for us it makes an excellent second car.
Ugly???? I hope I'm around when someone tells my wife that her "baby" is ugly!
Al
OK, your wife's baby is not ugly. It is a very attractive phone booth on wheels. Curious though, with the super short wheel base, how it will do on snow/ice.
05 Dodge Ram 3500 SLT SC DRW 4X4 CTD G56 373's CAI,Edge Juice/Attitude,Jake,Rancho9000x,Torklift tie downs,Superhitch,Stable Loads
04 S&S Avalanche 9' with slide
26th Marines RVN 69-70 Semper Fi
M-14 was the only Woodstock I saw in 1969.
|
lesmore49

canada

Senior Member

Joined: 11/25/2004

View Profile

|
AlGreg wrote: I think there is a lot of misinformation about the Smart Car. My wife has one. The price is NOT $37k. It starts at $11,590 for the Smart Pure. This model lacks A/C and other features. My wife bought the Smart Passion that starts at $13,590. This includes A/C (with climate control), power windows, power door locks (remote), stereo with MP3 CD, sun roof, automatic transmition and many other standard features. There is also The Smart Passion Cabriolet, a convertible, that starts at $16,590. My wife's Smart is bright yellow and she ordered it without any options so her price was $13,590 plus tax, etc. It's made by Mercedes Benz, so you can be assured that it is a well built car. Someone said that it looks like a death trap. It is built around a NASCAR style safety cage and has a 4 star crash rating. I realize you said NASCAR style, not NASCAR roll cage...but it definitely isn't a NASCAR cage, which is routinely subjected to crashes at 150 mph+. Level 5 is the top rating, level 4 is fine, but is this frontal, side and back or just front. There are also the immutable laws of physics when something larger and heavier crashes into a lighter body....the smaller, lighter body takes the brunt of the collision forces. Our real life gas mileage has been 43-48 mpg. We drive mostly Adirondack Mountain roads and interstates. I have a friend who regularly gets over 50 with his. He pulls his behind his Winnebago and says it makes an excellent dinghy. If you factor in the higher price for premium gas, we would be getting the equivelent of about 40 MPG with regilar.
Someone talked about not being able to fit in it without opening the sun roof. I'm 6'2", 250 lbs and I have pleanty of room. I'm 6'3", 230 lbs. and I have been in a colleague's SMART. I found the passenger seat, did not have adequate thigh length and support, consequently I wasn't comfortable. Possibly there is a difference in our body types that accounts for your comfort and my discomfort. It is a very comfortable car and handles the mountain roads and interstates very well. When you are in one, it feels like a much larger car.
Someone mentioned the Chevy Volt. That will be priced (when they come out) at about $35,000. I mentioned the Chevy Volt and I also indicated that the technology will spread, quickly I assume, considering the anticipated demand. More volume invariably means lower prices, when it comes to technology.The Smart Car is here NOW and can save you a lot of money on gas. The reason that a diesel is not avalible in the USA has nothing to do with Smart not wanting to market it here. We have the diesel SMART here and with cars like the Fit and YARIS, getting mileage figures that are probably not too far off the gas SMART and given the fact that they are 4-5 passenger , have relatively good cargo area and are also reasonably priced, I feel the advantages of the SMART are limited. Especially considering the gas SMART, not the diesel, is the only engine available. I feel the added economy of the diesel is the most advantageous feature of the SMART. It is our government that has kept it out. It is a 2 seater so it is not for everyone, but for us it makes an excellent second car. Quite right, it is a 2 door and this is a disadvantage to the Matrix, Yaris, Vibe and Fit. My colleague who drives a SMART diesel is single and uses it for work, usually in city gridlock and to pick up a few groceries. She does use if for occasional highway driving, which it does OK at, but has indicated that this is not it's forte. We have a second car, a Vibe, which as many know is a Toyota Matrix with Pontiac badging and some differences in panels. It can seat 4 comfortably, 5 is a squeeze and the cargo potential is remarkable. Gas mileage using the Cdn. Gallon which is 20 % larger than a US Gallon is 36 MPG city, 46 MPG highway. I don't know what the American gallon figures are.
A VW Jetta diesel Station wagon diesel would get mileage I would think close to the gas Smart and offers more cargo area and passenger capacity than the SMART.
The Smart is not new technology, but it is good technology. It has been around Europe for many years and it's original intent was to provide a novel, tiny car that would be a vehicle that has parking advantages in crowded European cities. IMO, it is a indirect descendant of the '50's BMW Isetta, only much improved in safety and comfort. Nothing wrong with a Smart, but I believe there are viable options out there.
Ugly???? I hope I'm around when someone tells my wife that her "baby" is ugly!
Al
I think as you said the SMART is available now and that is true. If your needs require just 2 seats, you do city driving for the most part it is a good car to consider.
In Canada, Smarts have been available for awhile, before the US and we also have the diesel version. They don't get many second glances now and that is a good thing in my view as it is indicative that they are accepted, more so then when they first came to market.
The day is rapidly coming, some say it maybe here now, when we (Canadians and Americans)will primarily consider small, highly efficient, fuel stingy cars , a class which includes everything from the Smart to Vibe, Matrix,Fit, Yaris, etc.
This is a good thing. I find myself taking the Vibe, for city trips, more often than our traditional big Buick sedan or Astro.
It gets me from A to B quite well, at a considerable saving in city traffic. The Smart will do the same for those who choose this unique, fuel efficient auto.
* This post was
last
edited 10/04/08 09:54am by lesmore49 *
View edit history
|
|
|
|