DSteiner51

Wooster, Oh

Senior Member

Joined: 01/30/2004

View Profile

|
RoyJ wrote:
1st, as others have pointed out, a gas engine as a lot more engine braking than a diesel, due to the throttle plate. If I have ot guess, I'd say your engine has atleast double the retarding power as a diesel.
I keep seeing this over and over and over again on the internet. Can someone please point me to the engineering data to back this up? My experience with both gas and diesel farm tractors of the same make and model in both versions and also Ford manual tranny trucks say otherwise. When I designed equipment all the engineering data also said differently. Please! Anyone, post a link to ACTUAL engineering data. The one ton I now drive on occasion will go to idol while going down the road at 60mph when I take my foot off the accelerator pedal but that isn't because of the engine.
D. Steiner
|
Paul Clancy

BC Canada

Senior Member

Joined: 09/16/2005

View Profile

|
oldtrucks wrote: I've had trucks with and without, my latest without, and I prefer with. I added a PacBrake to my 03 Duramax and could comfortably roll down most grades without service brakes. I could roll off the East side of Donner Summit without brakes. I sold that truck and the 06 Duramax I have now doesn't have a brake yet. Going over Donner is completely different, even with the Allison I still feel like I'm on the brakes too much to keep the engine speed down
If I felt the need this seems like a better option on your truck (or mine)
http://bankspower.com/news/show/24-banks-speedbrak
|
oldtrucks

Grass Valley, CA

New Member

Joined: 05/25/2008

View Profile

Offline
|
Paul Clancy wrote: If I felt the need this seems like a better option on your truck (or mine)
http://bankspower.com/news/show/24-banks-speedbrak
This is probably the direction I'm heading on this truck
|
JIMNLIN

Big Cabin, OK

Senior Member

Joined: 09/14/2003

View Profile

|
DSteiner51 wrote: RoyJ wrote:
1st, as others have pointed out, a gas engine as a lot more engine braking than a diesel, due to the throttle plate. If I have ot guess, I'd say your engine has atleast double the retarding power as a diesel.
I keep seeing this over and over and over again on the internet. Can someone please point me to the engineering data to back this up? My experience with both gas and diesel farm tractors of the same make and model in both versions and also Ford manual tranny trucks say otherwise. When I designed equipment all the engineering data also said differently. Please! Anyone, post a link to ACTUAL engineering data. The one ton I now drive on occasion will go to idol while going down the road at 60mph when I take my foot off the accelerator pedal but that isn't because of the engine.
Its really very simple engineering. A gas engine has a throttle plate that creates vaccum at closed throttle in the intake manifold hense engine (vaccum braking). The diesel has no throttle plate hence no vaccum but its still pumping lots of air in closed throttle position.
My Dodge/Cummins with the NV5600 6 speed manual tranny has zero engine braking going down a grade with 11000 lbs pushing, with the Cummins at redline and closed throttle. It has about as much braking as if the tranny was in neutral. My Jacobs, or any of the newer EB's, make a world of difference with 180 hp for braking.
Do a google on diesel engine braking. Lots and lots of reading. Jacobs and Cummins/International and Navistar and all the exhaust brake manufactures have tech info for the reason diesel have little engine vaccum braking.
"good judgment comes from experience, and a lot of that comes from bad judgment" Will Rogers
'03 2500 QC Dodge/Cummins HO 3.73 6 speed manual Jacobs Westach Linex
'97 Park Avanue 28' 5er with two slides 16" BFG Commercial LTs
|
coolbreeze01

Redding, Ca

Senior Member

Joined: 08/24/2006

View Profile

Offline
|
Good post JIMNLIN.
After some of the comments, I really wonder if some folks have ever been in the cab of a diesel truck, let alone on a mountain road
2008 Dodge 3500 CTD LB SRW 4X4 6-Speed Auto
P3 Blue Ox Sway Pro
2007 Komfort 212
|
|
|
RoyJ

Vancouver, BC

Senior Member

Joined: 10/19/2006

View Profile

Offline
|
SoCalDesertRider wrote:
If you had bothered to read/quote my WHOLE post instead of just part of it, you would have known that I DO understand diesels and locking torque converters...
I never said you didn't understand. But in that specific quote, you were comparing the engine braking superiority of your gas truck with someone else's diesel.
And I wasn't just talking about locking converters, but the ratio of slip to total engine rpm. i.e. 2000 rpm slip is nothing on a 9000 rpm race engine, but a lot on a 3000 rpm diesel.
|
larry barnhart

wenatchee. wa usa

Senior Member

Joined: 03/30/2001

View Profile

Offline
|
Henry Wang wrote: Just got back from a weekend of camping in British Columbia Southern interior in the Osoyoos area. For those of you in the know, getting in and out of Princeton is the one of the proofing grounds for your truck's pulling power and more importantly the stopping ability.
With consistent 7 and 9% grade hills, your truck has it's work cut out for sure. A couple of weeks ago I installed exhaust brake and a digital gauge pack to monitor my engine from BD Power. This trip was the acid test.
On a 7% grade going down hill, I had my truck in drive position (D) with overdrive (OD) on coasting at 90 km/hour and I was actually slowing down without touching the brakes. In fact, I had to touch the gas once in a while just so I didn't slow down too much.
On a 9% grade going down hill, I was in D with OD off coasting at 70 km/hour and holding very steady. It didn't slow down further or speed up.
On the way up, my absolute highest temp for EGT was 905 degrees F (alarm set at 1050) and transmission was around 176 degrees F (alarm set at 230). Turbo boost was maxed just over 20 PSI (alarm set at 33). Very nice to know that I am not over working my engine.
The best part was the feeling that I can coast for a long ways down hill without touching my brakes, saving them for actual emergency stop or the hard corner at the bottom of the hill.
I highly recommend this upgrade for anyone who can afford it. I will likely make my money back by the reduced brake and rotor servicing cost and the safety improvement can't be quantified.
Henry we have over $5000.00 in air products on our truck and fifthwheel. In the beginning of our rving I heard lots of stuff like (I never needed that air stuff and we did ok or way too much money butI didn't remember asking them for a loan so it really didn't matter what they thought) Same deal for you so enjoy the safer ride.
chevman
chevman
2001 35 ft avalon alpenlite RK
2005 3500 2wd duramax CC dually
prodigy
easyrider/reese airhitch
trailair center point suspension
JT Strong Arm Stabilizers
KSH 55 inbed fuel tank
Garmin 2720
scanguage II
TD-EOC
Induction Overhaul Kit
|
MadMav

Colorado Springs, CO

Senior Member

Joined: 03/12/2007

View Profile

Offline
|
For those post earlier.....there is a wonderfull article in the Sep 09 Diesel World magazine for install and test of the Banks Speedbrake for the 08 DMax Very nice article. Does the same thing the Dodge's factory EB does, and works too.
Guess it works on 04 and never Dmax. That's cool!
Mav
* This post was
edited 07/03/09 02:18pm by MadMav *
'08 Dodge 3500 SLT Mega Cab Dually, 6.7l/6 speed.
'08 Winners Circle 36SRV-H5
Pair of '09 Polaris Sportsman 550 XP's
'05 Polaris Trail Boss 330
'03 Yamaha TTR125LR
1 wife, 2 kids, 3 dogs, 2 cats
|
countryrose

Redding, Ca

Senior Member

Joined: 11/14/2005

View Profile


Good Sam RV Club
Offline
|
It appears that Ford and Dodge truck owners are more apt to add Engine Brakes, why is that?
Gary
2009 Bighorn 3400RL
2008 Chevy 3500HD DRW
DuraMax w/allison
|
Paul Clancy

BC Canada

Senior Member

Joined: 09/16/2005

View Profile

|
Good question and I'm not sure it's a correct assumption, but assuming it is
I'd guess it's because grade braking was introduced early on in the dmax/allison 01 and the other manufacturers had nothing competitive with that so eb installs provided a solution. I recall some worry about valve float with eb use but I'm unsure if that was a specific manufacturer. Regardless there are many good options for all now -eb standard on the dodge and grade braking on the other 2 with the option of adding eb on ford and dmax/or speedbrake on the dmax only.
|
|
|